Articles features
Did the British Empire have any benefits for India? No, says Tharoor
Jaipur, Jan 25
How should we view the British Empire and its legacy for its former colonies? Was it one of the world's greatest modernising forces, as some historians claim, or was it only a destructive bane? The latter, says Congress politician Shashi Tharoor who maintains the only two benefits for India were cricket and the English language.
Tharoor contested the contentions of co-panellist, British historian, author and MP Tristram Hunt, that the benefits included rule of law and an effective parliamentary system, saying he was not sure how good the latter has been for India.
"The system of governance of a small island nation was sought to be transplanted to a nation where there were not only ideological differences, but a bewildering range of diversities," he said, at a session titled "Empire" at the Jaipur Literature Festival here on Monday.
On the idea of rule of law, Tharoor contended it was part of the normal evolution of society and India could have achieved it for itself.
"You don't need foreigners to come and oppress you for benefit of development," he asserted.
"(Historian) Niall Ferguson (who has termed the British Empire a great modernising force) has not questioned for whose benefit it was done. I only accept cricket and the English language," said Tharoor.
Hunt, who had stepped in for Ferguson who wasn't able to make it for the event, contended that there was renewed interest in the Empire in his country -- where it had been absent for years from the school curriculum -- as Britain took decisions on its place in the world.
The author of "Ten Cities that Made an Empire", which seeks to chart the changing nature of the British Empire through 10 (formerly) imperial cities spread though out the world, Hunt said the empire had had an influence on his country too -- and still has.
"British politics are becoming like Indian politics. The centralised system is shifting to a more federal system... we are willing to take coalition partners," he said.
On the question of financial compensation for the damages to the former colonies' social and economic fabric, Tharoor, who had made headlines by making the demand at a debate in Oxford, said it should be a token amount, say a pound for every year of rule, rather than a ridiculous amount as had been calculated and would be "an exercise in absurdity and futility", could never be paid and besides, "India couldn't even know what to do with all that money".
Hunt noted that such a demand was more advanced in the former Caribbean colonies, but they instead of money, had sought help in education and development.
On whether bygones should be bygones, Tharoor said he agreed. "History cannot be undone. But it haunts our past and affects the future. By all means let bygones be bygones, but never forget it... we must remember it."
Hunt said he agreed. "We must interrogate, analyse and reinterpret the bygones," he said, adding he was quite sceptical of official apologies for historical wrongs.
(Vikas Datta can be contacted at vikas.d@ians.in)
Tharoor contested the contentions of co-panellist, British historian, author and MP Tristram Hunt, that the benefits included rule of law and an effective parliamentary system, saying he was not sure how good the latter has been for India.
"The system of governance of a small island nation was sought to be transplanted to a nation where there were not only ideological differences, but a bewildering range of diversities," he said, at a session titled "Empire" at the Jaipur Literature Festival here on Monday.
On the idea of rule of law, Tharoor contended it was part of the normal evolution of society and India could have achieved it for itself.
"You don't need foreigners to come and oppress you for benefit of development," he asserted.
"(Historian) Niall Ferguson (who has termed the British Empire a great modernising force) has not questioned for whose benefit it was done. I only accept cricket and the English language," said Tharoor.
Hunt, who had stepped in for Ferguson who wasn't able to make it for the event, contended that there was renewed interest in the Empire in his country -- where it had been absent for years from the school curriculum -- as Britain took decisions on its place in the world.
The author of "Ten Cities that Made an Empire", which seeks to chart the changing nature of the British Empire through 10 (formerly) imperial cities spread though out the world, Hunt said the empire had had an influence on his country too -- and still has.
"British politics are becoming like Indian politics. The centralised system is shifting to a more federal system... we are willing to take coalition partners," he said.
On the question of financial compensation for the damages to the former colonies' social and economic fabric, Tharoor, who had made headlines by making the demand at a debate in Oxford, said it should be a token amount, say a pound for every year of rule, rather than a ridiculous amount as had been calculated and would be "an exercise in absurdity and futility", could never be paid and besides, "India couldn't even know what to do with all that money".
Hunt noted that such a demand was more advanced in the former Caribbean colonies, but they instead of money, had sought help in education and development.
On whether bygones should be bygones, Tharoor said he agreed. "History cannot be undone. But it haunts our past and affects the future. By all means let bygones be bygones, but never forget it... we must remember it."
Hunt said he agreed. "We must interrogate, analyse and reinterpret the bygones," he said, adding he was quite sceptical of official apologies for historical wrongs.
(Vikas Datta can be contacted at vikas.d@ians.in)
3 hours ago
Left flank of Democratic Party has setback with defeat of radical in Wisconsin primary
5 hours ago
Veteran White House reporter breaks 26-year silence on Clinton’s 2000 Pakistan decoy plane
5 hours ago
Houthis launch fresh ballistic missile attack on Yemen's Red Sea port city
7 hours ago
CPI-M MP John Brittas files privilege motion against BJP's Sushmita Dev over 'lungi wala' remark; Oppn extends support
7 hours ago
The Indian Panorama's "America@ 250" Special Edition launched by GOPIO
10 hours ago
K'taka bans sale & distribution of tobacco, nicotine products for 1 year; urges public to build addiction-free state
11 hours ago
Vijay Sethupathi's film with Balaji Tharaneetharan titled 'Baththa'; film to hit screens on October 1
11 hours ago
Lisa Ray reveals the impact of chemotherapy on her body: ‘I went into menopause at 37’
11 hours ago
Wamiqa Gabbi chops long tresses, flaunts new short-hair look
11 hours ago
‘Haiwaan’ trailer starring Akshay Kumar, Saif Ali Khan sets stage for gritty, unsettling narrative through striking use of silhouettes
11 hours ago
Gurinder Chadha shares an unseen wedding moment, recalls videographer telling her, ‘An Indian bride never smiles’
11 hours ago
Radhika Pandit calls Yash her ‘favourite YES’ as they mark 10 years of engagement
11 hours ago
Geetu Mohandas heaps praise on Manish Malhotra for Kiara Advani’s ‘Toxic’ look