Headlines
Sonia Gandhi: Autumn of the matriarch (Column: Political Circus)
Even as Sonia Gandhi prepares to pass the baton to her children in the run-up to the Uttar Pradesh elections, it is obvious that she is not only opting for semi-retirement a few years too early but also that she is leaving the Congress in more of a derelict state than ever before in its 131 years.
At 69, Sonia is only four years older than Narendra Modi. In the normal course, she could have carried on for several more years.
But indifferent health has apparently forced her to opt for a change of guard at the party's helm with Rahul Gandhi being groomed to take over as the party chief, although there is little doubt that she will continue to play a major role in the Congress and in the country's politics in the foreseeable future.
When the history of these times is written, her retreat from formal leadership will however be seen to have taken place when the party is going downhill. She will not be handing over a healthy organization to her children but an ailing one.
From this standpoint, her stewardship can be said to have marked the twilight period of the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty. There is little doubt that Sonia Gandhi will be held responsible by chroniclers for this sad state of affairs if only because she has been -- and still is -- in sole command of the party. As a result, its successes and failures cannot but be attributed to her.
It was in 2004 that the Congress tasted success under her leadership. But hindsight suggests that it was an achievement by default rather than on its own steam.
According to Atal Behari Vajpayee, the BJP's defeat was the result of popular anger and disenchantment caused by the Gujarat riots.
As the Hindutva storm-troopers violated the raj dharma of neutrality in Gujarat, the Congress gained by being in the right place at the right time.
With Sonia Gandhi's popularity ratings second only to Vajpayee's at the time, it was evident that the electorate voted for her rather than for the Congress.
The success of 2004 was confirmed by an even bigger victory in 2009 when the Congress crossed the 200-seat mark in the Lok Sabha. The party seemed to be going from strength to strength.
But, then, the wheels began to turn and the decline which began from 2011-12 is still continuing. There is little doubt that Sonia Gandhi is responsible for this slide. A major reason is the disconnect between her and the popular preference for economic reforms.
As a recent book on P.V. Narasimha Rao has pointed out, a sizable section of Congressmen were against the then prime minister opening up the economy.
Indeed, Sonia and the anti-reforms Congressmen still live in the 1970s and 1980s. Unfortunately for them, India has moved on -- a trend which Narendra Modi detected and capitalized on with his pitch for development. The Congress, therefore, has been left behind.
But economic obtuseness is not the only reason the party has floundered under Sonia Gandhi. An even greater blunder is her unwillingness to build up a second rung of leadership apart from her own children.
Even there, Sonia Gandhi apparently prefers to distinguish between Rahul and Priyanka although the latter is palpably more popular among the party's rank and file and the people in general.
Sonia Gandhi appears to have acquired the trait of backing members of the family from her imperious mother-in-law, who also pushed her sons to the forefront instead of allowing the provincial leaders to play a larger role in national politics as in the early days of the Congress.
While Indira Gandhi groomed Sanjay first and then Rajiv to step into her shoes, Sonia Gandhi wants Rahul Gandhi to take over with Priyanka Vadra following some distance behind.
The disastrous fallout of this obsession with the dynasty is obvious. The consequences are all the more unfortunate because Rahul Gandhi lacks the charisma of his forebears.
However, it will not do to blame Sonia Gandhi alone for the Congress's plight. An equal responsibility has to be borne by the senior party members, none of whom has had the guts to point out to her the follies of her ways.
It is only pressure from below which has led to Priyanka Vadra being given a greater role in the Uttar Pradesh elections. Being more of an amiable, "natural" politician than her grumpy brother, the ordinary members of the party feel that she will fetch more votes than Rahul Gandhi.
Any other party or its leader would have banked on the personable Priyanka Vadra long ago to turn the organization's fortune around. But Sonia Gandhi's preference for her son has made her back him -- even if his inadequacies are evident.
The Congress, at the moment, is hoping for Modi to stumble so that it can find its way back to power. But the prime minister has been reasonably steady on his feet so far, although the Hindutva hotheads have been trying to queer the pitch for him with their anti-Muslim and anti-Dalit antics.
The Congress, therefore, is facing a bleak autumn with an even more depressing political winter before it.
14 hours ago
Mathematicians claim proof of 167-year-old Riemann hypothesis using AI, human methods
14 hours ago
Gold, silver plummet as Fed rate fears trigger selloff
18 hours ago
US Department of Agriculture hit by cyberattack this week: Report
20 hours ago
Bulgarian FM appreciates India's efforts to resolve Black Sea conflict
20 hours ago
Manipur spurious liquor tragedy: Death toll rises to 13, around 300 fall ill
21 hours ago
'Glaring hypocrisy': Pinarayi Vijayan slams Rahul Gandhi over Israel remarks
21 hours ago
Penelope Cruz excited for first feature film under her production banner
22 hours ago
Jane Seymour takes a trip down memory lane with ‘Dr. Quinn’ Christmas nostalgia
22 hours ago
Heli Daruwala on working with Bhuvan Bam: We laughed so much on set that our stomachs hurt
22 hours ago
Madhuri Dixit recalls seeing ‘at least four or five ‘Nisha's wearing that purple sari’ from Hum Aapke Hain Koun till today
22 hours ago
Hanu-Man makers announce 'Hanuman 2– The Rise of Vanaras'; film to feature Panja Vaisshnav Tej in the lead
22 hours ago
ASHA workers' protest enters 5th day; Karnataka BJP asks Priyanka Gandhi to honour Rs 15,000 promise
22 hours ago
Bengal plans Maha model screening to detect fake transgender claimants, Bangladeshis
